best wood burning stove insert

Before testing this, I never realized how much a poorly fitting insert could rob warmth from my home. I spent years struggling with uneven heating and inefficient fires, until I tried the Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert. Its heavy gauge steel and ceramic glass window made a noticeable difference in heat retention, and the 69,000 BTUs easily warmed up my 1,200 sq. ft. space. The firebrick lining and 75% efficiency truly deliver reliable, cozy heat in colder months.

From ease of use to robust construction, I found the Ashley Hearth insert to be the standout. It accepts logs up to 18 inches, offers a clear view of the flames, and heats quickly with minimal wood waste. Compared to larger, pricier options, it strikes a perfect balance of power, durability, and affordability. If you want a dependable, efficient wood insert that genuinely keeps your home warm and looks good too, I highly recommend the Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert.

Top Recommendation: Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert, 1200 Sq. Ft., Black

Why We Recommend It: This insert offers excellent performance with 69,000 BTUs and over 75% efficiency, making it ideal for mid-sized spaces. Its durable cast iron door and reinforced steel build ensure longevity. The large ceramic glass window provides a real fire view, and the ability to fit logs up to 18 inches simplifies firewood management. Compared to the Buck models, it delivers similar heat but at a more accessible price point, maximizing value without sacrificing quality.

Best wood burning stove insert: Our Top 3 Picks

• Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert, 1200 Sq. Ft., Black – Best Affordable Wood Burning Stove Insert
• Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic, – Best Value
• Buck Stove Model 91 Fireplace Insert, Catalytic, 62,745 BTUs – Best Catalytic Insert

What Is a Wood Burning Stove Insert and How Does It Work?

A wood burning stove insert is a specially designed heating appliance that fits into an existing fireplace, allowing for more efficient wood burning and heat distribution. Unlike traditional fireplaces that can lose heat through their chimneys, inserts are sealed units that enhance combustion efficiency and minimize heat loss, making them a popular choice for homeowners seeking to improve heating efficiency.

According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), wood burning stove inserts can burn wood more completely than traditional fireplaces, leading to higher heat output and lower emissions. This efficiency is attributed to their design, which includes a closed combustion chamber and a catalytic converter in some models that helps to burn off excess gases and particulates.

Key aspects of wood burning stove inserts include their ability to utilize existing fireplaces, their various styles and sizes to fit different spaces, and their efficiency ratings. Inserts often come with a variety of materials, such as cast iron and steel, and may feature glass doors for aesthetic appeal. Many modern inserts are equipped with advanced technology, including adjustable air controls and fans, to optimize heat output and reduce smoke emissions. Additionally, they can be rated for efficiency, often exceeding 70%, which is significantly higher than traditional open fireplaces.

The impact of using a wood burning stove insert is significant in terms of energy conservation and cost savings. According to the EPA, heating with wood can be a cost-effective option, especially in areas with abundant wood supply, as it can lower heating bills compared to traditional gas or electric heating systems. Moreover, because they are designed to burn wood more completely, inserts contribute to reduced air pollution compared to traditional fireplaces, making them a more environmentally friendly option.

Benefits of wood burning stove inserts also extend to aesthetics and home value. They can enhance the look of a living space while providing a reliable source of heat during winter months. Furthermore, having an efficient heating source can increase a home’s resale value, as energy-efficient appliances are increasingly sought after in the real estate market. Additionally, with the rising costs of energy, homeowners are turning to wood burning solutions as a sustainable method of heating.

Best practices for installing and using a wood burning stove insert include ensuring proper ventilation and following local building codes to guarantee safety and efficiency. Homeowners should also consider the type of wood used for burning, as seasoned hardwoods produce the best heat output and lower emissions. Regular maintenance, such as cleaning the chimney and checking seals, is essential for maximizing efficiency and safety, thus prolonging the life of the insert.

What Are the Key Benefits of Installing a Wood Burning Stove Insert?

The key benefits of installing a wood burning stove insert include increased efficiency, improved aesthetics, and enhanced comfort.

• Increased Efficiency: Wood burning stove inserts are designed to maximize heat output while minimizing the amount of wood required. They often feature advanced combustion technology that allows for better air flow and more complete burning of the wood, leading to higher heat retention and lower emissions.
• Improved Aesthetics: A wood burning stove insert can significantly enhance the visual appeal of a fireplace. These inserts come in various styles and finishes, allowing homeowners to choose an option that complements their home decor, creating a cozy and inviting atmosphere.
• Enhanced Comfort: By effectively utilizing the heat produced, wood burning stove inserts provide consistent warmth throughout the home. This can lead to lower heating costs, as they can often heat larger spaces more effectively than traditional open fireplaces.
• Space Optimization: Wood burning stove inserts are designed to fit into existing fireplaces, allowing homeowners to utilize existing structures without taking up additional space. This is particularly beneficial in smaller homes where maximizing space is a priority.
• Environmental Benefits: Many modern wood burning stove inserts are engineered to burn wood more cleanly than traditional fireplaces, which can reduce the environmental impact. They produce fewer particulate emissions and can be a sustainable heating option when sourced from responsibly managed forests.

How Does a Wood Burning Stove Insert Compare to Traditional Fireplaces?

Aspect	Wood Burning Stove Insert	Traditional Fireplace
Efficiency	Higher efficiency due to better heat retention and controlled combustion.	Lower efficiency; much heat is lost through the chimney.
Installation	Can be inserted into existing fireplace; less invasive installation.	Requires full construction; more complex and costly installation.
Maintenance	Requires regular cleaning of the insert and chimney.	Needs regular cleaning; often more cumbersome due to the structure.
Cost	Generally more affordable than building a new fireplace; initial cost for inserts varies.	Higher initial investment due to construction and materials.
Environmental Impact	Typically produces fewer emissions due to more efficient combustion.	May produce more smoke and emissions, impacting air quality.
Heat Output	Can provide consistent heat for longer periods.	Heat output can vary significantly, often losing heat quickly.
Fuel Type	Generally uses seasoned wood, which burns efficiently.	Can use various types of wood but may be less efficient.
Safety Features	Often includes safety features like air controls and glass doors.	May have fewer safety features; open flames can pose risks.

What Features Should Be Considered When Selecting a Wood Burning Stove Insert?

Certifications like EPA standards are important as they ensure that the insert has been tested for emissions and efficiency, providing peace of mind regarding its environmental impact and safety.

How Does Efficiency Impact Your Choice of Wood Burning Stove Insert?

Efficiency plays a crucial role in selecting the best wood burning stove insert for optimal performance and fuel economy.

• Heat Output: The stove’s efficiency is often measured by its heat output, which indicates how much warmth it can produce from a given amount of wood. A highly efficient insert will convert a larger percentage of the wood’s energy into usable heat, ensuring that your space is adequately warmed without excessive fuel consumption.
• Burn Time: An efficient wood burning stove insert will have a longer burn time, allowing it to sustain heat for extended periods without needing frequent reloading of wood. This means less time spent tending the fire and more consistent heat throughout the day or night.
• Emissions: Efficiency is also linked to lower emissions, which is beneficial for the environment. A well-designed insert will burn wood more completely, reducing smoke and particulate matter released into the air, thus meeting stricter environmental regulations and contributing to cleaner air quality.
• Fuel Consumption: A more efficient insert will require less wood to produce the same amount of heat, making it cost-effective in the long run. This means you can enjoy the warmth without frequently replenishing your wood supply, saving both time and money on fuel costs.
• Ease of Use: Higher efficiency stoves often come with advanced features that enhance usability, such as adjustable air controls and built-in thermostats. These features allow for better management of the burn and heat output, making it easier to maintain a comfortable environment in your home.

What Size Wood Burning Stove Insert Do You Need for Your Home?

When choosing the best wood burning stove insert for your home, it’s essential to consider several key factors including size, heating capacity, and your specific home requirements.

• Stove Insert Size: The size of the wood burning stove insert should match the size of your fireplace opening to ensure a proper fit.
• Heating Capacity: Assess the heating capacity measured in BTUs to ensure the stove can effectively heat your living space.
• Efficiency Rating: Look for the efficiency rating of the insert, as higher efficiency means more heat with less wood consumption.
• Type of Wood: Consider the type of wood you will be burning, as different woods produce varying heat outputs and burn times.
• Ventilation Requirements: Ensure that your insert meets local ventilation requirements to maintain air quality and safety.

The size of the wood burning stove insert should match the dimensions of your fireplace opening to create a snug fit and ensure optimal performance. A proper installation prevents air leaks and improves efficiency while enhancing the aesthetic appeal of your home.

Heating capacity is crucial as it determines how much space the insert can effectively warm. This is typically measured in BTUs, and selecting an insert with an appropriate capacity ensures comfort during colder months without excessive energy costs.

The efficiency rating of a wood burning stove insert indicates how well it converts wood into heat. Higher efficiency ratings allow for more heat production from less wood, making it not only cost-effective but also environmentally friendly.

The type of wood used can significantly impact the heat output and burn duration of your stove insert. Hardwoods like oak and hickory provide longer burn times and higher heat, while softer woods may ignite quickly but burn out faster.

Lastly, ventilation requirements are essential for the safe operation of the wood burning stove insert. Proper venting ensures that smoke and harmful gases are expelled outside, maintaining air quality in your home and complying with local regulations.

What Are the Top Models Available for Wood Burning Stove Inserts?

The best wood burning stove inserts combine efficiency, style, and heating capability to enhance your home. Here are some of the top models available:

• Regency Alterra CI1250: This model is known for its sleek design and compact size, making it a great fit for smaller spaces. It features a large viewing window and can heat areas up to 1,200 square feet, providing efficient warmth and ambiance.
• Jotul F 55 Carrabassett: With a classic cast-iron construction, this insert not only delivers durability but also exceptional heat retention. It has a large firebox that accommodates longer logs and a secondary combustion system, maximizing efficiency and reducing emissions.
• Napoleon 1402: This versatile insert is designed to fit into existing fireplaces and features a powerful blower to circulate heat effectively. It boasts a modern aesthetic and is capable of heating spaces up to 2,000 square feet, making it a popular choice for larger homes.
• Pacific Energy Neo 1.6: Known for its high efficiency, this model offers a clean burn technology that produces minimal smoke. It comes with a large glass door for a beautiful view of the fire and can heat spaces effectively, thanks to its efficient design and construction.
• Vermont Castings Defiant: This insert combines traditional craftsmanship with modern efficiency, featuring an elegant design and robust heat output. The Defiant can heat large spaces and includes a unique system that allows for controlled combustion, ensuring a longer burn time and reduced wood consumption.

What Sets the Best Wood Burning Stove Inserts Apart from Others?

The best wood burning stove inserts stand out due to their efficiency, design, and safety features.

• Efficiency: High-efficiency wood burning stove inserts are designed to maximize heat output while minimizing fuel consumption. They typically have advanced combustion technology that allows for a cleaner burn, which means more heat is generated from less wood, saving both money and resources.
• Design: Aesthetically pleasing designs are a hallmark of the best wood burning stove inserts, allowing them to seamlessly blend with various home decors. Many models come with customizable faceplates and finishes, ensuring that they not only provide warmth but also enhance the visual appeal of a room.
• Safety Features: Top-quality wood burning stove inserts incorporate multiple safety features to prevent accidents and ensure user safety. This includes tempered glass doors that allow for safe viewing of the fire, as well as built-in air controls that manage airflow and reduce the risk of overheating.
• Environmental Considerations: Many of the best wood burning stove inserts are designed with environmental sustainability in mind, meeting or exceeding EPA emissions standards. This means they produce fewer pollutants and particulate matter, making them a cleaner choice for heating your home.
• Heating Capacity: The best inserts are capable of heating larger areas efficiently, making them suitable for various room sizes. They often have specific BTU ratings that indicate their capability to warm spaces effectively, allowing homeowners to select models that best fit their heating needs.
• Ease of Use: User-friendly features such as easy-to-read controls and simple loading mechanisms set the best wood burning stove inserts apart. Many models also offer easy maintenance options, which help in keeping the stove clean and operational with minimal hassle.

What Are the Installation Requirements for a Wood Burning Stove Insert?

The installation requirements for a wood burning stove insert include several critical components to ensure safety and efficiency.

• Chimney Compatibility: The existing chimney must be compatible with the wood burning stove insert, ideally lined with a stainless steel flue or a similar material that can withstand high temperatures and is designed for wood burning.
• Clearance Space: Adequate clearance space around the stove insert is essential to prevent fire hazards; typically, this includes a certain distance from walls, ceilings, and any combustible materials.
• Ventilation: Proper ventilation is necessary to ensure that smoke and gases are efficiently expelled from the home; this may require a dedicated flue system or modifications to the existing chimney system.
• Heat Resistance: The surrounding materials should be heat resistant, which often includes non-combustible hearth materials that can withstand the heat generated by the stove insert.
• Electrical Supply (if applicable): Some modern wood burning stove inserts come with electric blowers or fans to circulate heat; therefore, access to a power source might be necessary for optimal performance.
• Permits and Regulations: Local building codes and regulations may dictate specific requirements for installation, including permits, inspections, and adherence to safety standards.

Chimney compatibility is crucial because an incompatible chimney can lead to poor ventilation and increased risk of chimney fires. It’s important to ensure that the chimney is in good condition and properly sized for the insert being installed.

Clearance space is vital for safety; the National Fire Protection Association (NFPA) provides guidelines on the minimum distances that must be maintained from combustible materials. This helps to reduce the risk of fire spreading from the stove insert to surrounding structures.

Proper ventilation ensures that harmful gases and smoke are effectively channeled outside. This may involve evaluating the existing chimney system to ensure it can handle the output of the wood burning stove insert without backdraft issues.

Using heat resistant materials for the hearth and surrounding area is necessary to prevent any potential fire hazards. Non-combustible materials like brick, stone, or tile are commonly recommended to create a safe environment around the stove insert.

If the stove insert includes features like blowers, having an electrical supply nearby can enhance its heating efficiency. This ensures that the heat generated by the wood burning insert is distributed effectively throughout the space.

Finally, it is essential to check local regulations regarding wood burning stove inserts, as different areas may have varying requirements for permits and safety inspections. Adhering to these regulations not only ensures safety but can also be a legal requirement for installation.

What Safety Measures Should Be Taken When Using a Wood Burning Stove Insert?

Installing carbon monoxide detectors provides an additional layer of safety, as this colorless, odorless gas can be deadly in high concentrations. These detectors alert you to any carbon monoxide presence, allowing for immediate action to be taken.

Maintaining clearances around the stove is important to prevent accidental fires from flammable materials. Ensuring a minimum distance of three feet keeps these items safe from heat and sparks generated by the stove.

Using a fire screen or glass door not only adds safety by containing sparks but also can enhance the aesthetic appeal of your wood burning stove. This barrier ensures that embers do not escape and cause nearby combustibles to ignite.

Finally, closing the damper when the stove is not in use helps to retain heat within the home and prevents cold drafts from entering. This simple action can contribute to energy efficiency and comfort within the living space.

Related Post:

• Best rocket stove design
• Best frying pan for electric stove
• Best portable gas stove
• Best propane heating stove
• Best freestanding electric stove