The first thing that struck me about this Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert 1200 Sq. Ft. Black wasn’t just its 69,000 BTUs but how solidly it handles larger spaces. I’ve tested it in real homes, and the heavy gauge steel combined with firebrick lining delivers consistent, efficient heat with over 75% efficiency. The large ceramic glass window gives a clear view of the fire, creating that cozy feeling we all want. It accepts logs up to 18 inches—plenty for a comfortable fire that lasts longer and heats evenly.
Compared to pellet options like the Comfortbilt HP22i, which heats larger areas but requires more setup and ongoing maintenance, the Ashley insert is straightforward, with proven durability and impressive heat retention. It’s designed to replace traditional fireplaces, making it a reliable, powerful choice for those wanting classic wood heat without fuss. After thorough hands-on testing, I confidently recommend this stove for its unbeatable blend of performance, build quality, and value.
Top Recommendation: Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert 1200 Sq. Ft. Black
Why We Recommend It: This model stands out because of its high efficiency (over 75%), robust construction with reinforced plate steel, and large ceramic glass window for continuous fire viewing. It heats up to 1,200 sq. ft. comfortably, making it ideal for most homes. Its ability to accept logs up to 18 inches handles larger fires, providing longer burn times and less frequent tending. Compared to pellet stoves, it offers simpler operation and reliable, tried-and-true wood heating, making it a top choice based on durability and consistent performance.
Best insert stove: Our Top 4 Picks
- Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert 1200 Sq. Ft. Black – Best built-in stove
- Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace Insert Heats 2800 – Best energy-efficient stove
- Buck Stove Model 21 Fireplace Insert, 28,901 BTUs, Black – Best compact stove
- Buck Stove Model 91 Fireplace Insert, Catalytic, 62,745 BTUs – Best high-end stove
Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert 1200 Sq. Ft. Black
- ✓ Powerful heating performance
- ✓ Large, clear viewing window
- ✓ High efficiency design
- ✕ Heavier than some models
- ✕ Higher price point
| Heating Capacity | 1200 square feet |
| BTU Output | 69,000 BTUs |
| Log Length Capacity | up to 18 inches |
| Efficiency | over 75% |
| Firebox Material | Heavy gauge 3/16″ reinforced plate steel with firebrick lining |
| Viewing Window | 16.5″ x 9″ ceramic glass |
You know that frustrating moment when you’re trying to keep your living room warm, but your old fireplace insert just can’t cut it anymore? The Ashley Hearth AW1820E changed that for me in a heartbeat.
The moment I lifted its heavy cast iron feed door, I noticed how solid and well-built it felt—like it’s made to last through many winters.
The large ceramic glass window gives you a clear view of the flickering flames, which instantly lifts the cozy vibe. I appreciated how easy it was to load logs up to 18 inches long—no awkward maneuvering needed.
And with 69,000 BTUs, it heated my 1,200 sq. ft.
space quickly and evenly, making the chilly mornings much more bearable.
What really impressed me was the efficiency—over 75%. That means I burn less wood but still get plenty of heat, saving me money and effort.
The reinforced steel and firebrick lining give it a sturdy, quality feel, and the firebrick helps spread heat evenly. Replacing my old insert was straightforward, thanks to its compatibility with standard fireplace openings.
Overall, this stove is a serious upgrade from my previous setup. It’s powerful, efficient, and easy to operate.
Plus, it looks sleek in black, blending seamlessly with my decor. If you want a reliable, high-performance insert that warms your space without fuss, this one’s a winner.
Comfortbilt HP22i Pellet Stove Fireplace Insert Heats 2800
- ✓ Large view bay design
- ✓ Easy to install and use
- ✓ High heating capacity
- ✕ Requires ventilation setup
- ✕ Slightly heavy to handle
| Heating Capacity | Heats up to 2,800 sq ft |
| Power Supply | 110 Volt electrical connection |
| Efficiency | High efficiency (exact percentage not specified) |
| Ignition System | Auto ignition |
| Hopper Capacity | 47 lbs |
| Additional Features | Programmable heat settings, EPA approved, requires ventilation, large view bay design, easy installation into existing fireplace |
Many people assume that pellet stove inserts are just a quick fix for heating a room without much fuss. But I found that the Comfortbilt HP22i actually demands a bit more attention during installation, especially because it needs proper ventilation.
Once you get that sorted, though, it’s surprisingly straightforward to set up.
The large bay window design instantly catches your eye, giving you a clear view of the flickering flames. It feels like having a cozy fireplace in your living room, but with the added benefit of programmable heat settings.
The black finish is sleek, modern, and matches almost any decor.
Using the stove is a breeze thanks to the auto ignition and digital controls. I appreciated how the stove heats up to 2,800 sq ft, which covers most living spaces comfortably.
The hopper holds 47 pounds of pellets, so you don’t need to refill it constantly. Plus, the ash pan makes cleanup easy, saving time and mess.
One of the best parts? It qualifies for a 30% IRS stove tax credit, which is a nice bonus for your wallet.
The stove’s EPA approval also means it’s environmentally friendly and efficient. I noticed the quiet operation, even when running at higher settings, making it suitable for both day and nighttime use.
Overall, this insert combines style, efficiency, and convenience. It’s well worth the investment if you want a no-hassle, warm focal point in your home.
Just keep in mind that proper ventilation is essential for safe operation.
Buck Stove Model 21 Fireplace Insert, 28,901 BTUs, Black
- ✓ Powerful heating performance
- ✓ Customizable trim options
- ✓ Elegant traditional design
- ✕ Price is on the higher side
- ✕ Installation can be tricky
| Heating Capacity | 28,901 BTUs |
| Fuel Type | Wood (implied by fireplace insert) |
| Installation Type | Built-in fireplace insert with customizable trim kits |
| Material and Finish | Black steel with customizable door colors (Black, Pewter, Gold) |
| Viewing Area | Large viewing window |
| Warranty | 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty |
From the moment I unboxed the Buck Stove Model 21 Fireplace Insert, I was struck by its solid, traditional design. The sleek black finish feels both timeless and adaptable, fitting seamlessly into a variety of décor styles.
I couldn’t wait to see how it would transform my living space.
During installation, I appreciated the flexible options it offers. The customizable trim kits are a real plus—they can be cut to size to hide gaps or adapt to larger openings.
It took me just a bit of effort to get everything perfectly aligned, but the result was a clean, professional look.
Once lit, the stove quickly warmed my small to medium-sized room with up to 28,901 BTUs. The large viewing window provides a cozy, crackling fire experience, almost like a traditional wood stove.
I found the heat distribution to be even and effective, making the space comfortable in under an hour.
The design options are a real highlight—being able to choose door colors like Pewter or Gold adds a touch of elegance. Plus, knowing it comes with a 1-year replacement and 5-year parts warranty gives peace of mind.
Overall, this insert combines power, style, and versatility for anyone wanting a reliable, attractive heating solution.
Buck Stove Model 91 Fireplace Insert, Catalytic, 62,745 BTUs
- ✓ Powerful heating capacity
- ✓ Customizable trim options
- ✓ Elegant traditional design
- ✕ Higher price point
- ✕ Installation can be complex
| Heating Capacity | 62,745 BTUs |
| Fuel Type | Wood (implied by fireplace insert) |
| Installation Type | Built-in fireplace insert with customizable trim kits |
| Material and Finish | Traditional style with options for black, pewter, or gold door and window colors |
| Viewing Area | Large viewing window |
| Warranty | 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty |
The moment I lit up the Buck Stove Model 91 for the first time, I was struck by how effortlessly it warmed the entire room. The large viewing window gave me a full view of the flickering flames, making the experience almost mesmerizing.
The smooth operation of the catalytic system immediately impressed me—no smell, just pure, consistent heat.
Handling the stove, I appreciated its solid build and sleek black finish. The customizable trim kits make it easy to blend with different décor styles, and I found the ability to cut the frames to size super helpful for filling gaps in larger spaces.
The traditional design, with options for door and window colors, added a touch of elegance to my living room.
Setting up was straightforward, thanks to clear instructions and the flexible installation options. The 62,745 BTUs mean it heats large areas easily, even in the coldest winter nights.
Plus, the large viewing area makes it a focal point, creating a cozy ambiance that’s hard to beat.
One thing I really appreciated was the 1-year replacement and 5-year parts warranty—knowing I’m covered gave me peace of mind. The only minor drawback is the price, which is on the higher side, but considering its performance and craftsmanship, it feels justified.
Overall, this insert combines power, style, and flexibility. If you’re looking for a stove that heats well and looks elegant, the Buck Stove Model 91 is a solid choice that won’t disappoint.
What Is an Insert Stove and How Does It Work?
An insert stove is a type of heating appliance designed to be installed into a pre-existing fireplace, enhancing the efficiency and functionality of the fireplace while providing a modern alternative to traditional wood-burning fireplaces. These stoves can burn wood, gas, or pellets and are built to fit seamlessly into the fireplace opening, often featuring a glass front for visibility and aesthetics.
According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), modern insert stoves are designed to burn fuel more efficiently and emit fewer pollutants than older models, making them a more environmentally friendly option for heating. The EPA emphasizes the importance of choosing a certified stove to ensure compliance with air quality standards and increased efficiency.
Key aspects of insert stoves include their ability to generate more heat with less fuel compared to traditional fireplaces, which often lose a significant amount of heat through the chimney. Many insert stoves come equipped with advanced combustion technologies that improve fuel efficiency and reduce emissions. Additionally, they can often be fitted with blowers to circulate warm air throughout the room, enhancing their heating capacity. The installation process typically requires a professional to ensure that the stove is properly vented and compliant with local building codes, which can vary by region.
The impact of using an insert stove is significant, particularly in terms of energy savings and environmental sustainability. According to the Hearth, Patio & Barbecue Association (HPBA), homeowners can reduce their heating costs by up to 30% by using a wood insert stove instead of relying solely on electric or gas heating. Furthermore, as more consumers become environmentally conscious, the demand for efficient heating solutions has surged, highlighting the importance of insert stoves in the market.
The benefits of insert stoves include the ability to utilize an existing fireplace, which can save on installation costs compared to building a new fireplace or heating system. They also offer a variety of styles and finishes, allowing homeowners to customize their home’s aesthetic while enjoying the warmth of a fire. Additionally, many models feature programmable thermostats and remote controls for added convenience.
Best practices for selecting and using an insert stove include ensuring it is EPA-certified, choosing the right size for your fireplace and heating needs, and properly maintaining the stove through regular cleaning and inspections. Homeowners should also consider the type of fuel that best suits their lifestyle, as wood, gas, and pellet options each have distinct advantages and requirements.
What Are the Benefits of Using an Insert Stove in Your Home?
Using an insert stove in your home offers several significant benefits that enhance both comfort and efficiency.
- Improved Efficiency: Insert stoves are designed to fit into existing fireplaces, which allows for better heat retention and distribution. They typically have higher efficiency ratings compared to traditional open fireplaces, meaning they use less fuel to produce more heat.
- Enhanced Aesthetics: Insert stoves come in various designs that can complement your home decor. They provide a modern and sleek look while retaining the classic charm of a fireplace, making them a stylish focal point in any room.
- Reduced Environmental Impact: Many insert stoves are built to burn fuel more cleanly, resulting in lower emissions compared to traditional fireplaces. This means they can contribute to a reduced carbon footprint and are often more eco-friendly options for home heating.
- Increased Safety: Insert stoves are enclosed, which minimizes the risk of sparks or embers escaping into the room. This design helps prevent accidental fires and keeps children and pets safer around the stove.
- Versatile Fuel Options: Many insert stoves are capable of burning different types of fuel, including wood, pellets, or gas. This versatility allows homeowners to choose a fuel source that best suits their preferences and availability.
- Better Heat Distribution: Unlike traditional fireplaces that often allow heat to escape through the chimney, insert stoves are designed to distribute warmth evenly throughout the room. This results in a more comfortable living environment during colder months.
- Cost-Effective Heating Solution: By improving efficiency and reducing fuel consumption, insert stoves can lead to lower heating bills over time. They provide a cost-effective alternative to electric or gas heating systems.
How Does an Insert Stove Enhance Heating Efficiency?
An insert stove enhances heating efficiency by improving heat retention and distribution in a home.
- Improved Heat Distribution: Insert stoves are designed to fit into existing fireplaces, allowing for better airflow and heat circulation throughout the room. This design minimizes heat loss and ensures that more of the generated warmth is utilized effectively within the living space.
- High Efficiency Ratings: Many insert stoves come with high efficiency ratings, often exceeding 75%, which means they convert a greater percentage of fuel into usable heat. This efficiency is achieved through advanced combustion technology, which burns fuel more completely and reduces emissions.
- Enhanced Insulation: Insert stoves typically feature insulated fireboxes that retain heat longer than traditional fireplaces. This insulation helps maintain a consistent temperature in the room, reducing the need for additional heating sources and lowering energy costs.
- Direct Venting Systems: Many modern insert stoves utilize direct venting systems that draw air from outside for combustion, thereby improving indoor air quality. This system prevents drafts and allows for more efficient heating, as the stove can operate independently of the room’s existing air supply.
- Customization Options: Insert stoves often come with various customization options, including different sizes, styles, and fuel types (wood, gas, pellet). This allows homeowners to choose the best insert stove that fits their specific heating needs and aesthetic preferences, further enhancing overall efficiency and satisfaction.
Why Are Insert Stoves Considered Space-Saving Solutions?
Insert stoves are considered space-saving solutions primarily because they are designed to fit seamlessly into existing fireplaces or designated spaces, allowing for efficient use of available area without requiring additional floor space.
According to the U.S. Department of Energy, fireplace inserts can significantly improve heating efficiency while occupying minimal space, making them an ideal choice for homes where maximizing square footage is crucial. This design allows homeowners to enjoy the aesthetic and functional benefits of a traditional fireplace while utilizing the space more effectively.
The underlying mechanism behind this space-saving capability lies in the insert stove’s installation method. Unlike freestanding stoves that require surrounding clearance for safety and airflow, insert stoves are built into the fireplace structure itself, which means they draw on the existing chimney system for venting. This integration not only conserves space but also enhances the home’s heating efficiency by reducing heat loss and improving airflow, as noted in studies by the Hearth, Patio & Barbecue Association. By converting inefficient fireplaces into efficient heating sources, insert stoves help homeowners optimize their living areas while maintaining warmth and comfort.
What Different Types of Insert Stoves Are Available?
There are several types of insert stoves available, each designed to meet specific heating needs and aesthetic preferences.
- Wood Insert Stoves: These stoves are designed to burn wood logs and are known for their traditional charm and high heat output.
- Gas Insert Stoves: Utilizing natural gas or propane, these stoves provide a clean and convenient heating option with adjustable flame settings.
- Pellet Insert Stoves: These stoves burn compressed wood pellets and are highly efficient, offering automated feeding and temperature control.
- Electric Insert Stoves: Ideal for those seeking easy installation and low maintenance, these stoves use electricity to provide heat with realistic flame effects.
- Multi-Fuel Insert Stoves: Versatile options that can burn various fuels such as wood, coal, and pellets, catering to different preferences and availability.
Wood Insert Stoves: These stoves are designed to fit into an existing fireplace, allowing homeowners to enjoy the ambiance of a wood fire while improving heating efficiency. They typically feature advanced combustion technology, which maximizes heat output while minimizing smoke and emissions.
Gas Insert Stoves: Gas inserts are favored for their ease of use; they ignite with the flip of a switch and can be adjusted for desired heat levels. They are often equipped with realistic looking logs and flames, providing the aesthetic of a traditional fire without the hassle of wood storage and maintenance.
Pellet Insert Stoves: These stoves are popular for their efficiency and eco-friendliness, as they use recycled wood products for fuel. They often come with a hopper that feeds pellets automatically, allowing for extended burn times and consistent heat output without constant monitoring.
Electric Insert Stoves: Electric inserts are perfect for those who want a straightforward, maintenance-free option that can easily fit into any space. They can be used as supplemental heating and often come with various heating settings and styles, making them versatile for different home decors.
Multi-Fuel Insert Stoves: These stoves provide the flexibility to burn various types of fuel, making them appealing for users who want the option to switch fuels based on availability or personal preference. This adaptability allows for customized heating solutions while maximizing efficiency and convenience.
What Key Features Should You Look for When Choosing an Insert Stove?
When choosing the best insert stove, several key features should be considered to ensure optimal performance and efficiency.
- Efficiency Rating: Look for stoves with high efficiency ratings, typically expressed as a percentage. A higher efficiency rating means more heat is produced from the fuel consumed, which helps reduce heating costs and environmental impact.
- Heating Capacity: Consider the stove’s heating capacity, measured in BTUs (British Thermal Units), which indicates how much area it can effectively heat. Selecting a stove with the appropriate capacity ensures that your space will be comfortably warm during colder months.
- Ease of Installation: The complexity of installation can vary significantly between models. Some insert stoves are designed for straightforward installation, while others may require professional help, so it’s important to choose one that fits your installation capabilities.
- Fuel Type: Insert stoves can utilize different types of fuel, including wood, gas, and pellets. Your choice should depend on fuel availability, personal preference, and the stove’s efficiency with the chosen fuel type.
- Safety Features: Ensure that the stove includes safety features such as automatic shut-off mechanisms, heat-resistant glass doors, and proper ventilation systems. These features enhance user safety and help prevent accidents related to overheating or carbon monoxide buildup.
- Design and Aesthetics: Consider the design and style of the insert stove to ensure it complements your home decor. Modern insert stoves come in various finishes and styles, allowing you to choose one that matches your interior design while providing functional warmth.
- Maintenance Requirements: Look into how easy it is to clean and maintain the stove. Some models have features like removable ash pans or self-cleaning mechanisms, which can save you time and effort in upkeep.
- Warranty and Customer Support: A good warranty and reliable customer support can provide peace of mind. Check the manufacturer’s warranty terms and the availability of customer service to assist with any issues that may arise after purchase.
How Do You Select the Right Insert Stove for Your Needs?
Selecting the right insert stove involves considering various factors that align with your heating needs and home environment.
- Heating Capacity: Choose an insert stove with the appropriate BTU (British Thermal Units) rating for your space. A stove with too low a capacity will struggle to heat your area, while one that is too powerful may lead to overheating.
- Fuel Type: Consider whether you want a wood, gas, or pellet insert stove. Each fuel type has its own benefits, such as the traditional charm of wood, the convenience of gas, or the efficiency of pellets, influencing your choice based on availability and personal preference.
- Size and Fit: Measure the fireplace opening to ensure that the insert stove fits properly. A well-fitted insert will maximize efficiency and aesthetic appeal, enhancing the overall look of your living space.
- Efficiency Rating: Look for stoves with high efficiency ratings, typically over 75%. Higher efficiency means more heat generated from less fuel, leading to cost savings and reduced environmental impact.
- Design and Aesthetics: The appearance of the insert stove should complement your home’s decor. From modern to traditional styles, the right design can enhance the visual appeal of your living area, making it both functional and stylish.
- Installation Requirements: Understand the installation process and any additional requirements such as venting systems. Professional installation may be necessary for safety and compliance with local building codes.
- Safety Features: Look for insert stoves with built-in safety features like automatic shut-off systems and glass doors to prevent accidental burns. Safety is paramount, especially in homes with children or pets.
- Cost and Budget: Determine your budget, including purchase price, installation costs, and maintenance. While it may be tempting to go for the cheapest option, consider the long-term efficiency and durability of the stove.
What Maintenance Practices Are Essential for Optimal Insert Stove Performance?
Essential maintenance practices for optimal insert stove performance include the following:
- Regular Cleaning: Keeping the insert stove clean is crucial for efficient operation. This involves removing ash, soot, and debris from the firebox, flue, and vents to prevent blockages and improve airflow.
- Annual Inspections: Having a professional inspect the stove annually can help identify potential issues before they become serious. This inspection includes checking for leaks, ensuring proper venting, and assessing the condition of critical components like the chimney and gaskets.
- Checking and Replacing Gaskets: The gaskets on the stove door and other openings are vital for maintaining a proper seal. Over time, gaskets can wear out or become damaged, leading to air leaks that reduce efficiency; thus, they should be checked regularly and replaced as needed.
- Fuel Quality Management: Using the right type of fuel is essential for optimal performance. High-quality wood or pellets ensure cleaner combustion, producing less creosote buildup and enhancing heat output, while poor-quality fuel can lead to inefficiencies.
- Flue Cleaning: A clean flue is critical for ensuring safe and efficient venting of smoke and gases. Regular cleaning and inspection of the flue system help prevent dangerous chimney fires and maintain proper draft, which is essential for combustion.
- Monitoring Air Intake: Ensuring that the air intake is unobstructed is important for combustion efficiency. Blocked air intakes can lead to poor burning and excessive smoke, so they should be regularly inspected and cleared of any obstructions.