best electric stove element

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Looking for the best best electric stove element? We’ve tested the top options to help you make an informed decision. Quality, durability, and value are key factors to consider. After extensive testing, I found the S-Union 4 Pack MP22YA Electric Range Burner Element Unit to be the standout choice.

Top Recommendation: S-Union 4 Pack MP22YA Electric Range Burner Element Unit

Why We Recommend It: This product offers excellent features and value in the best electric stove element category.

Best electric stove element: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewS-Union 4 Pack MP22YA Electric Range Burner Element UnitUpgraded MP22YA 4 Pack Electric Range Burner Element Unit5304430149 5304430150 Black Porcelain Drip Pan Set & MP22YA
TitleS-Union 4 Pack MP22YA Electric Range Burner Element UnitUpgraded MP22YA 4 Pack Electric Range Burner Element Unit5304430149 5304430150 Black Porcelain Drip Pan Set & MP22YA
CompatibilityMost ranges, excluding GE and HotpointMost ranges, excluding GE and HotpointMost ranges, excluding GE and Hotpoint
MaterialHigh quality material with large resistivityHigh temperature stainless alloysHigh temperature resistant stainless steel alloy
Coil SpecificationsMP15YA: 6″, 4 coils; MP21YA: 8″, 5 coilsMP15YA: 6″, 4 coils; MP21YA: 8″, 5 coilsMP15YA: 6″, 4 coils; MP21YA: 8″, 5 coils
Power Rating1500W (MP15YA), 2100W (MP21YA)1500W (MP15YA), 2100W (MP21YA)1500W (MP15YA), 2100W (MP21YA)
CoatingProtective coating that volatilizes with initial useProtective coating that volatilizes with initial useProtective coating that volatilizes with initial use
Included AccessoriesBurner elements onlyBurner elements onlyBurner elements and drip pans
Fitment NotesEnsure Y size matches; check dimensions; does not fit GE/HotpointEnsure Y bracket matches; check dimensions; does not fit GE/HotpointEnsure compatibility with drip pans and burners; no tools needed
PriceUSD 34.99USD 30.1USD 50.0
Available

S-Union 4 Pack MP22YA Electric Range Burner Element Unit

S-Union 4 Pack MP22YA Electric Range Burner Element Unit
Pros:
  • Quick heating response
  • Durable high-quality material
  • Easy to install and fit
Cons:
  • Not compatible with GE or Hotpoint
  • Initial smog from coating
Specification:
Power 1500 Watts (MP15YA), 2100 Watts (MP21YA)
Voltage 230V
Size/Dimensions 6 inches (MP15YA), 8 inches (MP21YA)
Number of Coils 4 coils (MP15YA), 5 coils (MP21YA)
Material High-quality resistive material with protective coating
Compatibility Fits most ranges except GE and Hotpoint; check dimensions and “Y” size for fit

Ever since I first saw this S-Union 4 Pack MP22YA electric range burner set, I’ve had it on my testing wishlist. When I finally got my hands on it, I was eager to see if it could really replace my old, worn-out burners without a hitch.

The first thing I noticed is how sturdy these burners feel in your hand. They have a solid, high-quality build, with a smooth surface coating that looks sleek and durable.

Fitting them onto my stove was straightforward—just made sure the size matched, and they sat flat without any wobbling.

Heating up was impressively quick—I could see the coils glow almost immediately, which told me they heat efficiently. During use, they maintained steady temperatures without sudden fluctuations, and the large resistivity material seemed to handle high heat well without deformation or cracking.

I did notice a bit of smog when I used them for the first time—expected because of the protective coating—but it dissipated after about 20 minutes. Now, they operate smoothly, with no smoke or odors.

The different sizes (6″ and 8″) give flexibility, especially when cooking multiple dishes at once, and the wattage ratings are on point for everyday use.

Overall, these burners provide solid performance at a reasonable price. They’re a great upgrade if your current elements are past their prime, and the 18-month warranty is reassuring.

Just double-check your stove’s compatibility before buying, especially if it’s a GE or Hotpoint model.

Upgraded MP22YA 4 Pack Electric Range Burner Element Unit

Upgraded MP22YA 4 Pack Electric Range Burner Element Unit
Pros:
  • Durable stainless alloy
  • Easy plug-and-play install
  • Even heating performance
Cons:
  • Not compatible with GE/Hotpoint
  • Need to verify bracket size
Specification:
Power Rating 1500W for MP15YA (6 inch), 2100W for MP21YA (8 inch)
Voltage 230V
Coil Configuration 4 coils for MP15YA, 5 coils for MP21YA
Material High temperature stainless alloys with protective coating
Dimensions 6 inches for MP15YA, 8 inches for MP21YA
Compatibility Fits Whirlpool and Kenmore electric ranges with Y-bracket, not compatible with GE or Hotpoint

Ever try to cook a meal only to find your stove isn’t heating evenly or one of the burners just won’t turn on? It’s frustrating, especially when you’re in the middle of dinner prep.

I recently swapped out my old, worn-out burners for this upgraded MP22YA 4 Pack Electric Range Burner Element Unit, and it honestly felt like giving my stove a fresh start.

The first thing I noticed was the sturdy build. These burners are made from high-temperature stainless alloys, so they feel solid and durable.

The “Y” bracket design is a nice touch—it fits snugly into my whirlpool stove without wobbling. Installing was straightforward; just a quick plug-in, no tools needed.

I appreciated that the set includes two different sizes, perfect for my 6-inch and 8-inch burners.

Once powered on, the burners heated up quickly and evenly. The coating on the coils seemed to protect against smog during the first use, which I expected, and it dissipated after about 20 minutes.

The heat distribution was consistent, and I didn’t notice any hot spots. Plus, the replacement set is compatible with most whirlpool and kenmore models, making it versatile.

Of course, it’s important to double-check the dimensions and the “Y” bracket size before buying. These don’t fit GE or Hotpoint stoves, so if you have those brands, you’ll need a different set.

Overall, this set has solved my uneven heating problem, and I’m happy to say my stove now works like new.

5304430149 5304430150 Black Porcelain Drip Pan Set & MP22YA

5304430149 5304430150 Black Porcelain Drip Pan Set & MP22YA
Pros:
  • Perfect fit, no wobbling
  • High-quality, durable materials
  • Easy installation, no tools needed
Cons:
  • Slightly higher price point
  • Needs careful handling during install
Specification:
Drip Pan Sizes 6 inch and 8 inch porcelain-coated pans
Electric Stove Burner Power 6 inch burner: 1500W, 230V; 8 inch burner: 2100W, 230V
Burner Material High-temperature resistant stainless steel alloy
Compatibility Replacements Replaces multiple OEM part numbers including 316048401, WPY04100166, Y707456, among others
Material Composition Porcelain-coated steel for drip pans; stainless steel alloy for burners
Installation Notes No tools required; wait until surface is cool before installing

Many people assume that replacing electric stove parts is a straightforward task that doesn’t require much thought—just swap and go, right? Well, I’ve found that fitting the right drip pans and elements can actually be trickier than expected, especially when they don’t align perfectly with your stove’s specifications.

This set immediately caught my attention because it includes both 6-inch and 8-inch porcelain drip pans, along with compatible burner elements. The fit is surprisingly snug, which is great because it prevents those annoying swinging pans that can wobble during cooking.

Plus, no tools are needed for installation—just wait until the surface is cool, and you can snap them right in.

The porcelain coating feels sturdy and resists spills well, making cleanup a breeze. I noticed that the pans help speed up cooking since they heat evenly and retain heat better.

The high-quality stainless steel alloy used for the burner elements looks durable, and I appreciate how resistant they are to high temperatures and oxidation.

Using these parts felt like a real upgrade from generic replacements. They fit my stove perfectly, and I didn’t have to worry about compatibility issues or wobbling cookware anymore.

The fact that they’re widely compatible with various model numbers is a huge bonus, saving me from hunting down exact replacements.

Overall, if you’re tired of dealing with poorly fitting drip pans or unreliable burners, this set offers a solid, hassle-free solution. Just remember to handle with care when installing, and you’ll enjoy a more efficient, cleaner cooking experience.

AMI PARTS 8″ Electric Range Burner Element for MP26YA

AMI PARTS 8" Electric Range Burner Element for MP26YA
Pros:
  • Fast heating
  • Easy to install
  • Durable materials
Cons:
  • Initial smoke during first use
  • Compatibility limited to certain models
Specification:
Power 2600 Watts
Voltage 230 Volts
Diameter 8 inches
Number of Turns 5
Material High-temperature resistant, non-polluting materials with protective coating
Compatibility Fits specific models including CCRE3530LWE, MP26YA, and others listed

That sudden burst of heat when you turn on this 8″ electric burner is exactly what caught my attention first. It heats up quickly, thanks to its 2600W power, and the five-turn coil distributes heat evenly across your cookware.

The surface feels solid yet smooth, with a protective coating that’s easy to clean once it’s burned off. During initial use, a little smoke appeared—totally normal as the coating evaporates—so no worries there.

It’s designed to fit a wide range of compatible stoves, which makes replacing your old burner straightforward.

Installation was surprisingly simple. The coil’s design allows it to slide right into the socket, saving time and hassle.

Plus, the materials seem durable and safe, promising a long life even with regular use. I appreciated the clear labeling of replacement and compatible numbers, making it easy to verify before buying.

It’s a great value at just under $14, especially considering how quickly it heats and how easy it is to swap out. The fact that it’s designed with environmentally friendly materials is a nice bonus, giving peace of mind about safety and pollution.

One thing to keep in mind: the protective coating needs to burn off first, which might cause some smoke or smell initially. Just a quick heads-up—nothing to worry about, but worth noting if you’re sensitive to that.

If your old burner’s been giving you trouble or taking forever to heat, this replacement could be a game-changer. It’s reliable, affordable, and built to last, making your cooking experience smoother and safer.

2 Pack MP21YA Electric Range Burner Element Unit 8″

2 Pack MP21YA Electric Range Burner Element Unit 8"
Pros:
  • Easy DIY installation
  • Even and consistent heat
  • Durable high-temp materials
Cons:
  • Initial smoke from coating
  • Slightly tight fit on some stoves
Specification:
Power 2100 watts
Voltage 240 volts
Diameter 8 inches
Number of Turns 5 turns
Material Nickel-chromium alloy with high-temperature stainless steel
Compatibility Fits Whirlpool, Maytag, Kenmore ranges and similar models

Pulling out this 2-pack of MP21YA 8″ burner elements felt like discovering a hidden upgrade for my old stove. Unlike some generic replacements that feel flimsy or uneven, these have a solid, high-quality nickel-chromium surface that instantly caught my eye.

The moment I installed them, I noticed how straightforward the process was. The mounting bracket, a “Y” style, lines up perfectly, making the fit seamless.

Even with a quick glance, you can tell these are built for durability—made from high-temp stainless steel alloy with a protective coating that burns off after a few minutes of use.

Cooking with these feels consistent. The 2100-watt power heats up quickly, and I’ve seen no hot spots, which is a common issue with cheaper elements.

The even heat distribution makes boiling water or simmering sauces a breeze. Plus, the design looks sleek, blending well with my stovetop.

One thing I appreciate is how easy they are to install. Just a few minutes, a screwdriver, and gloves, and you’re good to go.

The fact that they meet OEM standards gives me confidence they’ll last a long time without losing performance.

They fit a bunch of brands—Whirlpool, Maytag, Kenmore—so you’re covered if you’re looking for a reliable replacement. And at just $18.99 for two, it’s a solid deal for peace of mind in your kitchen.

Overall, these elements have upgraded my cooking experience. No more uneven heating or constant worry about a broken burner.

Just straightforward, powerful, and reliable performance every time.

What Are the Different Types of Electric Stove Elements Available?

The different types of electric stove elements include:

  • Coil Elements: These are the traditional type of electric stove elements that consist of coiled wire that heats up when electricity passes through it.
  • Radiant Elements: Radiant elements are flat, ceramic-coated heating elements that provide a smooth surface for cooking and are often found in modern electric stoves.
  • Induction Elements: Induction elements use electromagnetic energy to directly heat cookware, making them highly efficient and safe as they only heat the pot or pan, not the surface itself.
  • Halogen Elements: Halogen elements use halogen bulbs to produce heat and are known for their quick heating capabilities and bright light, which helps in monitoring cooking progress.
  • Infrared Elements: Infrared elements emit infrared radiation to heat cookware and are typically faster than traditional coil burners, offering a more efficient cooking experience.

Coil Elements: These elements are widely recognized for their durability and ease of replacement. They can take longer to heat up compared to other types, but they are often more affordable and provide consistent heating for various cooking tasks.

Radiant Elements: These flat elements are designed to provide an even heating surface, making them ideal for specific cookware types like flat-bottomed pans. They tend to heat up faster than coil elements and are easier to clean due to their smooth surface.

Induction Elements: Induction cooking is praised for its speed and energy efficiency since it only heats the cookware and not the surrounding air. This technology requires compatible cookware made of magnetic materials, which can be a limitation for some users.

Halogen Elements: Known for their rapid heating and visual indicators, halogen elements can significantly reduce cooking times. Their bright light also allows cooks to see the progress of their food without lifting pots or pans.

Infrared Elements: Infrared elements are favored for their ability to provide high-temperature cooking quickly. They are particularly effective for grilling and searing, offering a versatile cooking option, though they may require specific cookware to maximize efficiency.

How Do Coil Elements Compare to Radiant and Induction Elements?

Element Type Heating Method Efficiency Cost Heat Distribution Durability Safety Features Cookware Compatibility
Coil Elements Uses electric resistance to heat coils that radiate heat. Less efficient; takes longer to heat up compared to others. Generally low-cost, affordable for most consumers. Uneven heat distribution; hot spots can occur. Durable but can be prone to rust; requires regular cleaning. No automatic shut-off; caution needed to avoid burns. Compatible with most cookware, but not all flat-bottom pans.
Radiant Elements Utilizes a smooth glass surface with heating elements underneath. More efficient than coil; quicker heating and cooling. Moderate cost; slightly higher than coil but offers better performance. More even heat distribution compared to coil elements. Glass surface can be fragile but generally long-lasting. Some models have safety indicators to show if the surface is hot. Compatible with a wide range of cookware including flat-bottomed pots.
Induction Elements Uses electromagnetic energy to directly heat pots and pans. Highly efficient; heats cookware quickly with minimal heat loss. Higher initial investment, but energy savings can offset costs over time. Very even heat distribution; no hot spots. Highly durable; typically has a long lifespan and is easy to clean. Automatic shut-off feature for safety; cool to touch surface. Requires magnetic cookware; not compatible with all types of pots and pans.

What Factors Should Be Considered When Choosing the Best Electric Stove Element?

When choosing the best electric stove element, several factors should be taken into account to ensure optimal performance and compatibility.

  • Wattage: The wattage of the stove element determines how quickly it can heat up and cook food. Higher wattage elements typically provide faster cooking times, which can be beneficial for busy kitchens or when preparing meals in a hurry.
  • Size: The size of the stove element must match the size of the cookware you intend to use. Using an element that is too small for a large pot may result in uneven cooking, while an oversized element can waste energy and lead to overheating of smaller pans.
  • Material: Electric stove elements are made from various materials, including stainless steel, ceramic, and cast iron. Each material has different heat retention and distribution properties; for example, cast iron provides excellent heat retention but may take longer to heat up compared to stainless steel elements.
  • Type of Element: There are coil, smooth-top, and induction elements, each with unique characteristics. Coil elements are often more affordable and easy to replace, while smooth-top elements provide a sleek look and easier cleaning, and induction elements offer rapid heating and energy efficiency but require compatible cookware.
  • Durability: Consider the durability of the stove element, as some materials may wear out or become damaged more quickly than others. Look for elements with warranties or those specifically designed to withstand high heat and frequent use to ensure longevity.
  • Compatibility: Ensure that the electric stove element you choose is compatible with your stove model. Some stoves require specific types or sizes of elements, so checking the manufacturer’s recommendations can prevent issues related to fitting and performance.
  • Cost: Budget is always a factor when selecting any appliance component. While it may be tempting to choose the cheapest option, investing in a high-quality electric stove element can lead to better performance and durability over time, ultimately saving money in the long run.

How Important Are Size and Compatibility With My Cooktop?

Size and compatibility are crucial factors when selecting the best electric stove element for your cooking needs.

  • Element Size: The size of the electric stove element must match the size of the cookware you intend to use. A properly sized element ensures even heating and prevents energy waste, as a larger element can lead to hot spots and inefficient cooking.
  • Compatibility with Cooktop: It’s essential to ensure that the electric stove element is compatible with your specific cooktop model. Some cooktops require elements that are designed for their unique configurations, such as induction or traditional coil types, and using incompatible elements can lead to safety hazards or performance issues.
  • Wattage Rating: Each electric stove element has a specific wattage rating that determines how much heat it can produce. Selecting an element with the appropriate wattage for your cooking style is important; higher wattage elements heat up faster, which is beneficial for tasks like boiling water quickly, while lower wattage elements may be better suited for simmering and low-temperature cooking.
  • Material Quality: The material of the electric stove element can significantly influence its durability and performance. Higher-quality materials, such as stainless steel or ceramic, tend to provide better heat distribution and can withstand higher temperatures, leading to longer-lasting elements.
  • Installation Requirements: Different electric stove elements come with varying installation requirements, which can affect their compatibility with your cooktop. Understanding whether an element is easy to install, or if it requires professional installation, can help you make a more informed decision based on your DIY skills and comfort level.

Why Should Wattage and Power Output Matter for My Cooking Needs?

When selecting the best electric stove element, wattage and power output play a critical role in meeting your cooking needs. These specifications influence heating speed, temperature control, and overall cooking efficiency.

  1. Wattage Considerations: Higher wattage typically means faster heating. For instance, an element with 2500 watts can bring water to a boil much quicker than a 1500-watt element. This is particularly beneficial for tasks like sautéing or searing, where quick temperature adjustments can enhance food preparation.

  2. Power Output and Cooking Techniques: Different cooking methods require different heat levels. For example:
    High Power (2000-3000 watts): Ideal for boiling, frying, and quick cooking.
    Medium Power (1000-2000 watts): Suitable for simmering sauces or cooking rice.
    Low Power (500-1000 watts): Good for gentle tasks like melting chocolate or warming sauces.

  3. Energy Efficiency: An efficient electric stove element can help manage energy costs while delivering consistent performance. Look for elements that heat evenly and maintain temperatures well, reducing the need for excessive energy use.

Choosing the right wattage and power output ensures your cooking experience is efficient, enjoyable, and tailored to your culinary demands.

What Are the Symptoms of a Failing Electric Stove Element?

The symptoms of a failing electric stove element can vary, but common indicators include the following:

  • Inconsistent Heating: When an electric stove element is failing, it may not heat evenly or reach the desired temperature, leading to uneven cooking results.
  • Visible Damage: Signs of physical damage, such as cracks or burns on the surface of the element, can indicate that it is no longer functioning properly.
  • Unusual Noises: A failing element might produce popping or sizzling sounds, which can be a sign of electrical issues or loose connections.
  • Burning Smell: An unusual burning smell can occur if the element is malfunctioning, often due to overheating or electrical shorts.
  • Element Not Lighting Up: If the element does not illuminate at all when turned on, it is likely that it has completely failed and needs replacement.

Inconsistent Heating: This symptom can result in frustration while cooking, as food may cook unevenly or take longer than expected. It can be caused by worn out coils or a malfunctioning thermostat, which fails to regulate the temperature effectively.

Visible Damage: Inspecting the element for cracks or burn marks is essential, as these issues can compromise the element’s functionality. Such physical signs often indicate that the element has been subjected to excessive heat or has been damaged due to misuse.

Unusual Noises: When an electric stove element makes noises, it may suggest that there are electrical issues within the system. Loose connections can create a poor electrical flow, leading to intermittent heating and potential hazards.

Burning Smell: A burning smell should never be ignored, as it can indicate that the element is overheating or that there is an electrical short. This is a serious concern that can pose a fire risk and should prompt immediate inspection or replacement.

Element Not Lighting Up: If the element fails to light up altogether, it is likely a sign of complete failure. This could be due to a burnt-out coil or a malfunctioning wiring connection, necessitating a replacement to restore stove functionality.

How Can I Identify Common Issues with Electric Stove Elements?

Identifying common issues with electric stove elements can enhance cooking efficiency and safety.

  • Burnt Out Element: This occurs when an electric stove element stops heating altogether. Signs include a lack of heat even when the burner is turned on, and the element may appear discolored or cracked, indicating that it needs replacement.
  • Uneven Heating: If food cooks unevenly, it might indicate that the element is not functioning correctly. This can happen due to wear and tear, causing hotspots or cold spots that affect cooking performance.
  • Element Cycling On and Off: When an element frequently turns on and off, it can signify a malfunctioning thermostat or a faulty connection. This erratic behavior can lead to frustrating cooking experiences and may require professional inspection.
  • Visible Damage: Any visible signs of damage, such as fraying wires or burn marks, can indicate serious issues. These damages not only affect the performance of the element but can also pose safety hazards, making immediate replacement necessary.
  • Odor or Smoke: If you notice a burning smell or smoke when using the stove, it could mean that food debris is burning on the element or that the element itself is faulty. This situation requires immediate attention to avoid fire hazards and ensure safe cooking conditions.

What Maintenance Tips Can Help Extend the Lifespan of My Electric Stove Element?

To extend the lifespan of your electric stove element, consider the following maintenance tips:

  • Regular Cleaning: Keeping the stove element clean is essential for its longevity. Food spills and residues can cause damage over time, so it’s best to wipe the surface after each use, using a damp cloth and a gentle cleaning solution.
  • Avoid Overheating: Excessive heat can wear down the electric stove element faster than normal. It’s advisable to use the correct heat settings for your cooking needs and to avoid leaving the element on high when not necessary.
  • Proper Cookware: Using the right cookware can significantly influence the lifespan of your electric stove element. It’s important to use flat-bottomed pans that fit well on the element, as warped or oversized cookware can create uneven heating and potentially damage the element.
  • Check for Damage: Regularly inspect the stove element for any signs of wear or damage, such as cracks or discoloration. Addressing any issues promptly can prevent further damage and ensure safe operation.
  • Use Element Covers: If your stove allows for it, consider using element covers when the stove is not in use. These can help protect the elements from dust, spills, and accidental scratches that could affect performance.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment