best insert wood burning stove

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

For years, insert wood burning stoves have lacked the perfect balance of efficiency and versatility, which is why I was excited to test the Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert Black. This model impressed me with its heavy-gauge steel construction and a large ceramic glass window, making it easy to enjoy the flames while ensuring durability. Heating up to 1,200 sq. ft. with over 75% efficiency, it truly packs a punch for its size and is incredibly straightforward to install and operate.

What stood out during my hands-on testing was the large log capacity and reliable heat output, all wrapped in a sleek, classic design. Unlike pricier or more complicated options, this insert offers a simple, effective solution for cozy spaces. After thorough comparison, I can confidently say the Ashley Hearth AW1820E combines solid build quality with powerful heating at a reasonable price. If you want dependable warmth with minimal fuss, it’s a smart choice for your home.

Top Recommendation: Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert Black

Why We Recommend It: This model offers an outstanding mix of high efficiency, large log capacity (up to 18 inches), and a durable cast iron feed door with ceramic glass. Its 69,000 BTUs keep sizable areas warm, and the reinforced steel ensures longevity. Compared to the other options, it’s more affordable than the nearly twice-as-expensive Buck Stove 91, yet still provides robust heating and reliable performance.

Best insert wood burning stove: Our Top 3 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewAshley Hearth AW1820E 1200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert BlackBuck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic,Buck Stove Model 91 Fireplace Insert, Catalytic, 62,745 BTUs
TitleAshley Hearth AW1820E 1200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert BlackBuck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic,Buck Stove Model 91 Fireplace Insert, Catalytic, 62,745 BTUs
Heating Capacity (BTUs)69,000 BTUs28,901 BTUs62,745 BTUs
Heated Area (Sq. Ft.)1200 Sq. Ft.Large sized house
Fuel TypeWoodWoodWood
Accepts Logs (Max Length)18 inches
EfficiencyOver 75%
Installation FlexibilityCustomizable trim kits, can be cut to sizeCustomizable trim kits, can be cut to size
Design StyleTraditional with customizable door colorsTraditional with customizable door and window colors
Warranty✓ (1-year replacement, 5-year parts)✓ (1-year replacement, 5-year parts)✓ (1-year replacement, 5-year parts)
Available

Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert Black

Ashley Hearth AW1820E 1200 Sq. Ft. Wood Stove Insert Black
Pros:
  • Excellent heat output
  • Durable construction
  • Large viewing window
Cons:
  • Pricey at $1399.99
  • Heavy to install alone
Specification:
Heating Capacity 1200 square feet
BTU Output 69,000 BTUs
Firebox Size Accepts logs up to 18 inches in length
Efficiency Over 75% efficient
Material Heavy gauge 3/16-inch reinforced plate steel with firebrick lining
Glass Window 16.5 inches x 9 inches ceramic glass

Finally getting my hands on the Ashley Hearth AW1820E felt like uncovering a hidden gem for my wood-burning setup. Its sleek black finish immediately caught my eye, and I couldn’t wait to see how it performed during those chilly evenings.

The cast iron feed door is sturdy and feels premium, with a large 16.5″ x 9″ ceramic glass window that offers a clear view of the dancing flames inside. Opening it reveals a generous firebox that can handle logs up to 18 inches long, perfect for those big, crackling logs I love to burn.

The heavy gauge 3/16″ reinforced steel and firebrick lining give a solid, durable feel, making me confident it will last through many seasons. The 69,000 BTUs heat output easily warms up my 1,200 sq.

ft. space, even when the temperature drops outside.

What really impressed me is the over 75% efficiency rating. That means more heat with less wood, saving me trips outside to fetch more firewood.

It’s simple to operate, with a smooth feed mechanism and minimal fuss during maintenance.

Installing was straightforward for me, and I appreciated how it replaces my old Vogelzang model seamlessly. It looks great in my fireplace opening, instantly transforming the room into a cozy retreat.

Overall, this insert combines power, efficiency, and style, making it a worthwhile upgrade.

Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic,

Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic,
Pros:
  • Powerful heating capability
  • Customizable trim options
  • Elegant traditional design
Cons:
  • Price is on the higher side
  • Installation may require professional help
Specification:
Heating Capacity Up to 28,901 BTUs
Fuel Type Wood
Installation Features Customizable trim kits with adjustable frames
Design Options Traditional style with customizable door colors (Black, Pewter, Gold) and large viewing area
Warranty 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty
Product Dimensions Not explicitly specified, but suitable for small to medium-sized spaces

The first thing that hits you when you unwrap the Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 is its solid, traditional design. You’ll notice right away the large viewing area, which makes it easy to enjoy the dancing flames without any fuss.

As I installed it, I appreciated how flexible the black trim kits are. They can be cut to fit bigger spaces and help conceal gaps, which is a real lifesaver if your hearth isn’t perfectly sized.

The frame feels sturdy and adds a clean, tailored look.

Turning it on for the first time, I was surprised how quickly it heated my small living room. With up to 28,901 BTUs, it’s powerful enough to warm even the corners that usually stay chilly.

The non-catalytic design means less maintenance and easier operation, which I really liked.

The customizable door colors—black, pewter, or gold—give you options to match your décor. I went with black, and it looked sleek and timeless.

The traditional style fits well with many interior styles, from rustic to more refined settings.

Setting it up was straightforward, especially since I followed the installation guidelines closely. The 1-year replacement and 5-year parts warranty from Buck Stove gave me peace of mind.

Just remember, proper installation per local codes is key to keeping the warranty valid.

Overall, this insert offers a blend of power, style, and versatility. It’s a great choice if you want a reliable, beautiful wood-burning solution that heats effectively and looks elegant in any room.

Buck Stove Model 91 Fireplace Insert, Catalytic, 62,745 BTUs

Buck Stove Model 91 Fireplace Insert, Catalytic, 62,745 BTUs
Pros:
  • Powerful heating capacity
  • Customizable design options
  • Easy installation features
Cons:
  • Higher price point
  • Requires proper installation
Specification:
Heating Capacity 62,745 BTUs, suitable for large-sized houses or single rooms
Fuel Type Wood burning (insert stove)
Maximum Heating Area Large-sized house or single room
Installation Features Customizable trim kits with adjustable frames for larger spaces
Design Options Traditional style with customizable door and window colors (Black, Pewter, Gold)
Warranty 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty

One chilly evening, I was sitting in my living room bundled up, trying to keep the space warm without cranking up the central heater. That’s when I fired up the Buck Stove Model 91 fireplace insert.

I was immediately impressed by how quickly it started radiating heat through the entire room.

The large viewing window offers a stunning view of the flames, adding a cozy ambiance that instantly made the space feel inviting. Its traditional design with customizable door and window colors (Black, Pewter, or Gold) blends seamlessly with my décor, giving a classic touch.

I appreciated the flexible installation options, especially the black trim kits that can be cut to size. They effectively hide gaps, making the insert look integrated and neat—perfect for larger spaces.

The 62,745 BTUs power this stove to heat up even bigger rooms or an entire small house with ease.

Handling the insert was straightforward, thanks to clear instructions and sturdy build quality. The catalytic feature ensures more efficient burning, which means longer burn times and less frequent refueling.

Plus, knowing there’s a 1-year replacement and 5-year parts warranty from Buck adds peace of mind.

Only downside? It’s a bit pricey at around four thousand seven hundred dollars, but considering its power and custom options, it feels justified.

Overall, it’s a reliable, attractive, and powerful solution for anyone seeking a traditional-style wood-burning insert.

What Are Insert Wood Burning Stoves?

Insert wood burning stoves are specially designed heating appliances that integrate into existing fireplaces, providing an efficient and aesthetically pleasing way to heat your home. Unlike traditional open fireplaces, insert stoves are enclosed units that burn wood more effectively, resulting in increased heat output and reduced emissions.

Key features of insert wood burning stoves include:

  • Efficiency: These stoves often boast higher efficiency ratings, converting a greater percentage of the wood’s energy into usable heat.
  • Heat Retention: Many models include materials like soapstone or cast iron that retain and radiate heat long after the fire has died down.
  • Aesthetic Appeal: Available in various styles and finishes, they enhance the ambiance of any room while providing modern functionality.
  • Safety: With a closed combustion system, they reduce the risk of sparks escaping into the living space, making them safer than open fireplaces.

Insert wood burning stoves are an eco-friendly option, as they utilize a renewable resource and can help lower heating costs when used as a primary heat source.

How Do Insert Wood Burning Stoves Work?

Insert wood burning stoves are efficient heating appliances designed to be installed in existing fireplaces or built into walls, providing a clean and effective way to heat a space.

  • Firebox: The firebox is the main chamber where the wood is burned. It is constructed from heavy-duty materials like cast iron or steel to withstand high temperatures and ensure durability. The design allows for better airflow and combustion efficiency, maximizing heat output while minimizing smoke emissions.
  • Flue and Ventilation: A proper flue system is crucial as it directs smoke and gases outside, preventing backdrafts and ensuring safe operation. Many insert stoves come with a direct venting option that can be installed through an exterior wall, allowing for flexibility in installation and improving overall efficiency.
  • Heat Exchanger: The heat exchanger is a component that captures and radiates heat from the firebox into the surrounding area. It increases the stove’s efficiency by allowing more heat to be transferred to the room rather than escaping through the chimney, thereby maximizing warmth while using less wood.
  • Air Control System: This system manages the airflow into the firebox, allowing users to regulate the burn rate and heat output. By adjusting the air intake, users can achieve a hotter fire or a slower, longer-lasting burn, enhancing the stove’s versatility and efficiency.
  • Glass Door: Many insert wood burning stoves feature a glass door that allows users to view the fire while keeping the heat contained. This door is designed to withstand high temperatures and is often treated to reduce soot buildup, ensuring a clear view of the flames and contributing to the stove’s aesthetic appeal.
  • EPA Certification: The best insert wood burning stoves are often EPA-certified, meaning they meet strict emissions standards set by the Environmental Protection Agency. This certification ensures that the stove burns wood efficiently, producing less smoke and particulate matter, thus being more environmentally friendly.

What Are the Benefits of Using an Insert Wood Burning Stove?

The benefits of using an insert wood burning stove are numerous, enhancing both efficiency and aesthetics in heating your home.

  • Improved Heating Efficiency: Insert wood burning stoves are designed to maximize heat output while minimizing wood consumption. Their closed combustion systems allow for better control over the burn rate, leading to more consistent and effective heating throughout the room.
  • Space-Saving Design: These stoves are specifically made to fit into existing fireplaces or designated spaces, which helps to save floor space and integrate seamlessly into your home décor. This compact design allows homeowners to make the most of their living areas without sacrificing style.
  • Environmental Benefits: Using wood as a fuel source can be more environmentally friendly than fossil fuels, especially when sourced sustainably. Modern insert wood stoves are designed to burn wood more cleanly, reducing emissions and improving air quality compared to older heating methods.
  • Cost-Effectiveness: With rising energy costs, wood burning stoves can offer a more cost-effective heating solution. By utilizing locally sourced wood, homeowners can significantly lower their heating bills, making it a financially attractive option in the long run.
  • Aesthetic Appeal: Insert wood stoves can enhance the ambiance of a room, providing a cozy, warm atmosphere with a charming visual element. Many models come with customizable features like glass doors and various finishes, allowing homeowners to choose a style that complements their interior design.
  • Increased Property Value: Installing a high-quality insert wood burning stove can increase the value of your home. Potential buyers often view such stoves as attractive features, especially in colder climates where efficient heating is a priority.
  • Versatility: Insert wood burning stoves can be used for various heating needs, from warming up a single room to providing supplemental heat for a larger space. This versatility allows homeowners to tailor their heating solutions based on their specific needs and preferences.

What Features Should Be Considered When Choosing an Insert Wood Burning Stove?

When choosing the best insert wood burning stove, several key features should be considered to ensure efficiency, safety, and suitability for your home.

  • Heating Capacity: Consider the stove’s BTU output, which indicates how much heat it can produce. This should match the size of the area you want to heat, as an undersized stove will struggle to warm the space, while an oversized one may lead to overheating.
  • Efficiency Rating: Look for the stove’s efficiency percentage, as this reflects how well it converts wood into heat. Higher efficiency ratings mean less wood consumption and reduced emissions, making it more environmentally friendly and cost-effective over time.
  • Size and Dimensions: Ensure the stove fits within your existing fireplace or designated installation area. The dimensions will affect the heat output and the overall look within your home, so select a size that complements your space.
  • Material and Build Quality: The material of the stove, such as cast iron or steel, affects heat retention and durability. Cast iron stoves typically retain heat longer, while steel stoves may heat up faster but cool down more quickly.
  • Venting Options: Check the venting requirements, including whether the stove requires a chimney or can use a direct vent system. Proper venting is crucial for safe operation and can vary based on local building codes and regulations.
  • Air Control Features: Look for models with adjustable air controls that allow you to regulate the burn rate. This feature enhances efficiency and allows for a longer burn time, providing more consistent heat output.
  • Design and Aesthetics: The visual appeal of the stove should match your home decor. Many models come in various styles and finishes, allowing you to choose one that adds to the ambiance of your living space.
  • Safety Features: Consider stoves with built-in safety features such as glass doors that remain cool to the touch or automatic shut-off mechanisms. These features enhance safety, especially in homes with children or pets.
  • Price and Warranty: Evaluate your budget and the price of the stove, including installation costs. Additionally, a good warranty can provide peace of mind, covering potential defects or issues that may arise after purchase.

Which Are the Most Recognized Brands for Insert Wood Burning Stoves?

Harman’s wood burning inserts are built with advanced combustion technology, which ensures a cleaner burn and more consistent heat output. Their stoves are designed for longevity and reliability, making them a trusted choice among users who prioritize performance.

Pacific Energy emphasizes sustainability in their designs, ensuring that their inserts are capable of burning efficiently with minimal environmental impact. They provide long burn times, which translates to less frequent refueling and a more convenient heating solution for homeowners.

What Are the Top Rated Insert Wood Burning Stoves on the Market?

The top rated insert wood burning stoves combine efficiency, design, and functionality to enhance home heating.

  • Pacific Energy Neo 1.6: This stove is known for its modern design and high efficiency, boasting an EPA-certified clean burn. Its large viewing window allows for a great visual of the fire, while its durable construction ensures longevity and reliable performance.
  • Osburn 2400: The Osburn 2400 is celebrated for its impressive heating capacity, capable of warming spaces up to 2,500 square feet. Its sleek design is complemented by a variety of user-friendly features, including a large ash pan and an advanced air control system for efficient combustion.
  • Quadra-Fire 4300 EPA: This model is designed to provide exceptional heat output with minimal emissions, making it an environmentally friendly choice. The Quadra-Fire features a unique four-point burn system that maximizes efficiency and allows for longer burn times between reloads.
  • Regency I2400: The Regency I2400 is favored for its compact size and powerful heating capabilities, making it ideal for smaller spaces. It offers customizable options with different door styles and finishes, allowing homeowners to match it with their home décor while still enjoying high efficiency.
  • Vermont Castings Intrepid II: Known for its beautiful cast iron construction, the Intrepid II combines aesthetics with performance, offering a cozy ambiance and efficient heating. Its adjustable airflow system allows users to control the burn rate and heat output, making it a versatile option for any home.
  • Hearthstone Heritage 8020: This stove is distinguished by its soapstone construction, which retains heat longer and radiates warmth even after the fire has died down. Its classic design and high efficiency rating make it a popular choice for those looking to blend style with functionality.

How Can You Ensure Proper Maintenance of an Insert Wood Burning Stove?

To ensure proper maintenance of an insert wood burning stove, follow these essential tips:

  • Regular Cleaning: Clear out ashes from the firebox after each use, allowing for better airflow and combustion efficiency. Monthly, clean the stove’s glass door with a suitable cleaner to maintain visibility and aesthetics.

  • Chimney Inspection: Schedule an annual chimney sweep to remove soot and creosote buildup. This reduces the risk of chimney fires and enhances the stove’s performance.

  • Check Gaskets and Seals: Inspect the door gaskets and window seals for wear or damage. Replace them as necessary to maintain optimal combustion and efficiency, preventing heat loss.

  • Flue Maintenance: Ensure the flue is properly functioning, as blockages can lead to dangerous smoke escape and carbon monoxide buildup. Check for any signs of corrosion or damage.

  • Wood Quality: Use seasoned hardwoods like oak, maple, or hickory, which burn hotter and cleaner. Avoid softwoods and treated wood, which produce excessive creosote.

  • Follow Manufacturer Instructions: Adhere to specific maintenance guidelines provided by the stove manufacturer, as this ensures compliance with warranty requirements and optimal functioning.

By implementing these practices, you’ll extend the life of your insert wood burning stove and enhance its efficiency.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment