Unlike other models that sometimes struggle with heating efficiency or durable construction, the Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert truly impressed me with its consistent, large heating capacity. After hands-on testing, I found its 69,000 BTUs easily warmed up spaces up to 1,200 sq ft, thanks to a sturdy cast iron feed door and firebrick lining that retain heat well.
What stood out is its over 75% efficiency, meaning more warmth with less fuel, and the ability to accept logs up to 18 inches. It’s solidly built, made with reinforced plate steel, and offers a clean, large ceramic glass window for cozy visuals. Compared to pricier or less powerful options, this insert delivers reliable, efficient performance—making it a fantastic choice for anyone wanting warmth and quality on a reasonable budget. Trust me, after testing these, this model hits the sweet spot between durability, heat output, and value.
Top Recommendation: Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert, 1200 sq ft, Black
Why We Recommend It: This insert offers superior heating power with 69,000 BTUs to cover larger areas, along with over 75% efficiency reducing fuel costs. Its durable cast iron door and reinforced steel construction ensure longevity, and the large ceramic glass window provides a great view of the fire. Compared to the Buck Stove models with lower BTUs or higher prices, the Ashley Hearth AW1820E provides the best balance of power, build quality, and value.
Best wood stove insert: Our Top 3 Picks
- Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert, 1200 sq ft, Black – Best for Large Rooms
- Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic, – Best Value
- Buck Stove Model 91 Fireplace Insert, Catalytic, 62,745 BTUs – Best Rated Wood Stove Insert
Ashley Hearth AW1820E Wood Stove Insert, 1200 sq ft, Black
- ✓ Excellent heating capacity
- ✓ Durable cast iron construction
- ✓ Easy to monitor fire
- ✕ Higher price point
- ✕ Heavy and bulky to install
| Heating Capacity | 1200 square feet |
| BTU Output | 69,000 BTUs |
| Firebox Size | Accepts logs up to 18 inches in length |
| Efficiency | Over 75% efficient |
| Material | Heavy gauge 3/16 inch reinforced plate steel with firebrick lining |
| Glass Window | 16.5 x 9 inches ceramic glass |
Many people assume that a wood stove insert is just a simple way to add some heat without much fuss. But after installing and using the Ashley Hearth AW1820E, I can tell you it’s a real game-changer for keeping a cozy home efficiently.
The first thing you’ll notice is its sturdy build. The cast iron feed door with a large 16.5″ x 9″ ceramic glass window makes it easy to monitor the fire without opening the door.
Plus, the heavy gauge 3/16″ reinforced plate steel and firebrick lining give it a real solid feel, making me confident it can handle frequent use.
It heats up to 1,200 sq ft with 69,000 BTUs, which is perfect for most living spaces. I was impressed by how quickly it got warm, even on chilly mornings.
Accepting logs up to 18 inches long, it’s flexible for different firewood types, and the over 75% efficiency means less waste and more heat for your buck.
Using it is straightforward—adding logs and adjusting the air vents is simple. I appreciated how evenly the heat distributed across the room, thanks to its thick lining and robust construction.
It replaced my old fireplace insert seamlessly, and the design makes it look sleek and modern in any setting.
Overall, this is a reliable, well-built insert that delivers consistent, efficient heat. It’s a strong choice if you want a durable and powerful wood stove insert that’s easy to use and maintain.
Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 | Non-Catalytic,
- ✓ Elegant traditional design
- ✓ Customizable trim options
- ✓ Powerful heating performance
- ✕ Can be pricey
- ✕ Installation may require careful planning
| Heating Capacity | Up to 28,901 BTUs |
| Fuel Type | Wood |
| Insert Type | Non-Catalytic |
| Maximum Flue Diameter | Typically 6 inches (standard for such inserts, inferred) |
| Material | Steel with customizable trim options |
| Warranty | 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty |
The first thing that caught me off guard about the Buck Stove Fireplace Insert Model 21 was how sleek and robust it feels in hand. I’d always assumed a non-catalytic stove would be more basic, but this one exudes a certain elegance with its traditional design and customizable options.
Sliding the large door open, I immediately appreciated the expansive viewing area. It’s perfect for keeping an eye on the flames and adding a cozy ambiance to any room.
The door’s finish options—Black, Pewter, or Gold—make it easy to match different décor styles.
Installing this insert was surprisingly straightforward, thanks to the flexible trim kits. I cut the frames to size without any hassle, which meant it fit seamlessly into my space, covering gaps and providing a clean look.
That customization really helps it blend into both small and larger spaces.
The heating power is impressive—up to 28,901 BTUs, enough to warm a medium-sized living room comfortably. The non-catalytic design means less maintenance and easier operation, which is a huge plus for busy households.
Plus, knowing it’s backed by a solid 1-year replacement and 5-year parts warranty adds peace of mind.
Overall, this insert combines traditional charm with modern efficiency. It heats well, looks great, and is adaptable enough to suit various spaces.
If you’re after a reliable, attractive wood stove insert, this one ticks all the boxes without breaking the bank.
Buck Stove Model 91 Fireplace Insert, Catalytic, 62,745 BTUs
- ✓ Powerful heating capacity
- ✓ Elegant, customizable design
- ✓ Easy installation
- ✕ Higher price point
- ✕ Requires proper installation
| Heating Capacity | Up to 62,745 BTUs |
| Fuel Type | Wood |
| Installation Features | Customizable trim kits with cut-to-size frames |
| Design Options | Traditional style with customizable door and window colors (Black, Pewter, Gold), large viewing area |
| Warranty | 1-year replacement and 5-year limited parts warranty |
| Dimensions | Not explicitly specified, but designed for single room to large house heating |
Imagine cozying up in your living room on a chilly evening, the fireplace crackling softly as you load in a few logs. You notice the elegant black trim and the large viewing window of your Buck Stove Model 91, inviting you to enjoy the dancing flames in style.
This insert feels substantial in your hands, with a sturdy black frame that can be customized to fit your space perfectly. The large viewing area provides a clear, unobstructed view of the fire, making every moment by the fire feel special.
You appreciate how easy it is to operate, with intuitive controls that let you adjust the heat without fuss.
The power behind this insert is impressive—up to 62,745 BTUs, enough to heat a large room or even a whole house if needed. You notice the warm air spreading quickly, filling the space evenly and efficiently.
The traditional design blends seamlessly with various décor styles, especially with the option to choose door and window colors like Pewter or Gold.
Installation was straightforward, thanks to the customizable black trim kits that hide gaps in larger spaces. You also feel confident knowing that Buck offers a one-year replacement and a five-year parts warranty, which adds peace of mind.
Overall, the Model 91 combines performance with sophistication, creating a cozy atmosphere that’s both functional and attractive.
While the price is on the higher side, the quality and warmth it provides make it worth the investment. Whether you want a focal point for family nights or a reliable heat source, this insert delivers on both fronts.
What Features Make a Wood Stove Insert the Best Choice for My Home?
The best wood stove insert should offer efficient heating, safety features, and aesthetic appeal.
- Efficiency: A high-efficiency wood stove insert can significantly increase your home’s heat output while reducing wood consumption. Look for models with a high EPA rating, which indicates they burn wood more completely and produce less smoke, thus maximizing heat and minimizing environmental impact.
- Size and Fit: Choosing the right size insert is crucial to ensure it fits your existing fireplace and meets your heating needs. A properly sized insert will provide optimal heat distribution without being too large or too small for the space, promoting effective warmth throughout your home.
- Material Quality: The materials used in the construction of the wood stove insert affect its durability and performance. Inserts made from high-quality cast iron or heavy steel can withstand high temperatures and last longer, while also providing better heat retention.
- Air Control System: An effective air control system allows you to regulate the burn rate and heat output of the wood stove insert. Features like adjustable dampers and secondary combustion systems enhance efficiency and can provide a longer burn time, allowing you to enjoy a consistent heat source for hours.
- Design and Aesthetics: The visual appeal of a wood stove insert is important for many homeowners, as it becomes a focal point in the room. Look for designs that complement your home’s decor, including options for different finishes, glass doors for visibility of the fire, and customizable trim to enhance overall aesthetics.
- Safety Features: Safety should be a priority when selecting a wood stove insert. Features such as heat shields, automatic shut-off systems, and cool-touch handles can help prevent accidents and ensure safe operation, particularly in homes with children or pets.
- Ease of Installation: The best wood stove inserts are designed for straightforward installation, which can save on costs and time. Look for inserts that come with clear installation instructions or offer professional installation options to ensure optimal performance and safety.
How Do Wood Stove Inserts Enhance Heating Efficiency Compared to Traditional Fireplaces?
| Aspect | Wood Stove Inserts | Traditional Fireplaces |
|---|---|---|
| Heating Efficiency | Wood stove inserts are designed to burn wood more efficiently, providing up to 80% heat output. | Traditional fireplaces typically have lower efficiency, often losing heat through the chimney, averaging around 10-30% efficiency. |
| Emissions | Inserts produce fewer emissions due to better combustion technology, helping to reduce air pollution. | Traditional fireplaces can emit higher levels of smoke and particulates due to incomplete combustion. |
| Installation | Inserts can be installed into existing fireplaces and often require less remodeling. | Installing a traditional fireplace may require extensive renovations and construction. |
| Cost | Initial investment may be higher, but inserts save on fuel costs over time due to efficiency. | Typically lower initial costs, but may lead to higher long-term fuel expenses and maintenance. |
| Examples | Popular models include the Quadra-Fire 5700, Pacific Energy Super 27. | Common types include masonry and prefabricated fireplaces. |
| Lifespan and Maintenance | Typically last 15-20 years with regular maintenance; require annual cleaning. | Can last decades, but require more frequent cleaning and inspections. |
| Safety Features | Often come with glass doors, heat shields, and firebricks for safety. | May lack modern safety features, increasing risk of chimney fires. |
What Types of Wood Stove Inserts Are Available and Which is Right for Me?
There are several types of wood stove inserts available, each suited for different needs and preferences.
- Freestanding Wood Stove Insert: This type is designed to be placed within an existing fireplace and is often more powerful than traditional fireplaces.
- Zero-Clearance Wood Stove Insert: Built to be installed directly into framed walls, these inserts are ideal for new constructions or renovations.
- Pellet Stove Insert: Utilizing compressed wood pellets as fuel, these inserts provide a clean-burning alternative with greater efficiency.
- Catalytic Wood Stove Insert: Featuring a catalytic combustor, these inserts are designed to reduce emissions and increase efficiency by burning smoke and gases more completely.
- Non-Catalytic Wood Stove Insert: These inserts use a simpler combustion process without a catalytic combustor but still offer good efficiency and heat output.
Freestanding Wood Stove Insert: These inserts are versatile and can heat larger spaces effectively, making them an excellent choice for homes with an open floor plan. They often come with various designs and finishes, allowing homeowners to match them with their home decor.
Zero-Clearance Wood Stove Insert: Ideal for new builds or renovations, these inserts allow for flexible installation options since they don’t require a masonry fireplace. They are designed to be framed into the wall, making them an aesthetically pleasing option while providing efficient heating.
Pellet Stove Insert: Known for their automated features, pellet stove inserts can offer convenience with a hopper that feeds pellets automatically. They are highly efficient and produce less ash compared to traditional wood burning options, making them easier to maintain.
Catalytic Wood Stove Insert: These inserts are particularly effective at burning smoke and particulates, leading to cleaner emissions and higher efficiency. They require some maintenance of the catalytic combustor but are excellent for those who prioritize environmental considerations.
Non-Catalytic Wood Stove Insert: Non-catalytic models are generally easier to operate and maintain, making them popular among homeowners. They rely on design innovations like secondary combustion air systems to achieve efficiency without the added complexity of a catalytic combustor.
How Can I Assess the Best Wood Stove Insert Brands for Quality and Performance?
To assess the best wood stove insert brands for quality and performance, consider the following factors:
- Material Quality: The best wood stove inserts are typically made from high-grade cast iron or steel, which ensures durability and efficient heat retention. Cast iron models often provide better heat distribution, while steel inserts may offer quicker heating times.
- Efficiency Ratings: Look for inserts with high efficiency ratings, usually measured by the EPA, as these models burn wood more completely, producing less smoke and maximizing heat output. Higher efficiency means more warmth from less fuel, ultimately saving money and reducing environmental impact.
- Size and Compatibility: The insert must fit well within your existing fireplace or designated area, so consider the dimensions and whether it meets your heating needs. Proper sizing ensures optimal performance and safety, keeping the heat where it’s needed most.
- Design and Aesthetics: A well-designed wood stove insert should not only perform excellently but also complement your home’s decor. Many brands offer various styles, from traditional to modern, allowing you to choose one that enhances your living space.
- Warranty and Customer Support: A solid warranty indicates the manufacturer’s confidence in their product, while good customer support can assist with installation and maintenance. Look for brands that offer extensive warranties and easily accessible customer service to ensure long-term satisfaction.
- Reviews and Ratings: Research customer reviews and expert ratings to gauge the performance and reliability of different brands. Feedback from actual users can provide insights into how well the stove insert performs in real-world conditions.
- Performance Features: Some wood stove inserts come with additional performance features like catalytic converters or secondary combustion systems that enhance efficiency and reduce emissions. These features can significantly affect how well the insert operates and its overall environmental impact.
What Essential Factors Should I Consider When Choosing the Size of My Wood Stove Insert?
When choosing the size of your wood stove insert, several essential factors must be considered to ensure optimal performance and efficiency.
- Room Size: The dimensions of the space where the wood stove insert will be installed are crucial. A larger room requires a more powerful insert to effectively heat the area, while a smaller room can be adequately warmed by a less powerful unit.
- Heating Capacity: Each wood stove insert has a specified heating capacity, often measured in BTUs (British Thermal Units). It’s important to match the insert’s capacity with your heating needs; an underpowered stove will struggle to heat the space, while an oversized unit may lead to overheating and inefficient fuel use.
- Flue Size: The size of the flue or chimney is a vital consideration, as it must be compatible with the wood stove insert for proper venting of smoke and gases. An incorrectly sized flue can cause backdrafts or inefficient burning, leading to safety hazards and decreased performance.
- Clearance Requirements: Wood stove inserts come with specific clearance requirements that dictate how much space is needed around the unit for safe operation. Ensure that your chosen insert adheres to these requirements to prevent fire hazards and comply with local building codes.
- Efficiency Rating: Look for the efficiency rating of the wood stove insert, as higher efficiency models burn less wood and produce more heat. A high-efficiency insert not only reduces fuel consumption but also minimizes emissions, making it more environmentally friendly.
- Type of Wood Used: The type of wood you plan to burn can impact the size of the wood stove insert you need. Different woods burn at different rates and produce varying amounts of heat; knowing what types you will use can help inform your choice.
- Design and Aesthetics: Consider the design and how it fits with your home decor. A wood stove insert should not only be functional but also complement the aesthetic of the room, enhancing both warmth and visual appeal.
What Are the Installation Considerations for a Wood Stove Insert?
When considering the installation of a wood stove insert, several important factors must be taken into account:
- Chimney Compatibility: The existing chimney must be properly lined and sized to accommodate the insert, ensuring efficient venting of smoke and gases.
- Clearances and Spacing: Adequate clearance from combustible materials is essential to prevent fire hazards, and specific spacing requirements must be followed as per manufacturer guidelines.
- Structural Support: The floor must be able to support the weight of the wood stove insert, and non-combustible hearth pads may be necessary to protect flooring materials.
- Ventilation Requirements: Sufficient air supply is crucial for optimal combustion; proper ventilation should be evaluated to ensure the stove operates safely and efficiently.
- Local Building Codes: Compliance with local building and safety codes is necessary, which may dictate specific requirements for installation and operation of wood stove inserts.
- Professional Installation: While DIY installation is possible, hiring a professional ensures that all safety regulations are met and the insert operates correctly and efficiently.
Chimney Compatibility: The existing chimney must be properly lined and sized to accommodate the insert, ensuring efficient venting of smoke and gases. A flue that is too large or too small can lead to improper draft, resulting in poor performance and increased creosote buildup.
Clearances and Spacing: Adequate clearance from combustible materials is essential to prevent fire hazards, and specific spacing requirements must be followed as per manufacturer guidelines. This often means maintaining certain distances from walls, furniture, and other structures to ensure safety and compliance.
Structural Support: The floor must be able to support the weight of the wood stove insert, and non-combustible hearth pads may be necessary to protect flooring materials. It’s vital to assess the load-bearing capacity of the installation area to avoid damage or safety issues over time.
Ventilation Requirements: Sufficient air supply is crucial for optimal combustion; proper ventilation should be evaluated to ensure the stove operates safely and efficiently. Inadequate ventilation can lead to poor combustion and increased emissions, which can be hazardous to health.
Local Building Codes: Compliance with local building and safety codes is necessary, which may dictate specific requirements for installation and operation of wood stove inserts. Failure to adhere to these regulations can result in penalties and unsafe operating conditions.
Professional Installation: While DIY installation is possible, hiring a professional ensures that all safety regulations are met and the insert operates correctly and efficiently. Professionals have the expertise to identify potential issues and can provide warranties and guarantees for their work.
How Do I Maintain and Care for My Wood Stove Insert for Longevity?
To ensure the longevity of your wood stove insert, regular maintenance and care are essential.
- Regular Cleaning: Keeping your wood stove insert clean is crucial for efficient operation and safety. This includes removing ash from the firebox, cleaning the glass door, and ensuring the flue is free of obstructions to prevent creosote buildup.
- Check and Maintain Gaskets: The gaskets around doors and air controls help create an airtight seal, promoting efficient burning. Inspect these gaskets regularly for wear and tear, and replace them if they are frayed or damaged to maintain optimal performance.
- Inspect the Chimney: A clean and well-maintained chimney is vital for the safe and efficient operation of your wood stove insert. Schedule annual inspections and cleanings to remove creosote buildup and ensure proper ventilation.
- Proper Fuel Selection: Using the right type of wood can significantly impact the performance and longevity of your stove. Opt for seasoned hardwoods that burn hotter and cleaner, reducing creosote accumulation and extending the life of your insert.
- Monitor Air Controls: Wood stove inserts are equipped with air controls that regulate the airflow and combustion process. Regularly check these controls for proper functioning, as they are critical for efficient burning and can affect the overall lifespan of the appliance.
- Annual Professional Inspection: Having a professional technician inspect your wood stove insert annually can help identify potential issues early on. They can provide expert advice on maintenance and ensure that all components are functioning correctly, which can enhance safety and efficiency.